Death of Karen Ballesteros
A Wichita County jury has found Matison Preville the son of a St Lucia SDA pastor guilty of capital murder in the death of Karen Ballesteros, sentencing the defendant to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Following five days of testimony, the jury deliberated for about 50 minutes before returning the guilty verdict in Wichita Falls, Texas.
District Attorney John Gillespie expressed appreciation for the jury’s swift decision, noting that key evidence presented during the trial played a critical role in the conviction. Among the primary evidence were photographs Preville took of himself less than an hour after the shooting, including one showing him smiling and giving a thumbs-up. District Attorney Gillespie stated that the selfie demonstrated Preville was proud of what he had done.
The prosecution also praised the Wichita Falls Police Department, stating that investigators’ rapid response after Ballesteros was reported missing helped preserve crucial evidence for the case.
During the trial, the defense argued that the state failed to prove Preville kidnapped Ballesteros, asserting there was no evidence he forced her into his truck or planned to take her to the field. Testifying in his own defense, Preville claimed the shooting occurred during a struggle over a shotgun and asserted that Ballesteros later shot herself in the head after he left to find help. The jury rejected the defense’s account and convicted Preville of capital murder.
District Attorney Gillespie stated that the verdict brings a measure of justice for Ballesteros’ family, including her nine-year-old son living in Colombia, who lost his mother as a result of the crime. Under Texas law, Preville receives an automatic appeal. Gillespie expressed confidence that the conviction will stand, noting that the trial involved very few objections and no major contested evidentiary matters.


